Skip to content

Survey study, 2023

Does attachment style affect how severe premenstrual symptoms are?

For women not on hormonal birth control, yes. Women with anxious attachment (being very worried in relationships) had more severe premenstrual symptoms through difficulty controlling emotions. Women on hormonal contraception did not show this pattern.

Early or limited evidence 289 female university students (165 naturally cycling, 124 using hormonal contraception)

What they did

Researchers surveyed 289 female university students (165 not on hormonal contraception and 124 on hormonal contraception) about their attachment style, how they handle emotions, and the severity of their premenstrual symptoms.

What they found

For naturally cycling women, anxious attachment was linked to more severe premenstrual symptoms, and this happened because of difficulty managing emotions. For women on hormonal contraception, this connection was not found.

What it means for you

For naturally cycling women, being anxious about relationships may increase premenstrual symptom severity through difficulty controlling emotions. Therapy addressing relationship anxiety might help. However, this was an observational study, so we cannot confirm this causes the symptoms. More research is needed.

165

Naturally cycling women

124

Women on hormonal contraception

289

Total women studied

About the study

Original title
Attachment style and premenstrual symptom severity: the mediating role of maladaptive emotion regulation
Authors
Anna Ishkova, Robyn L. Moffitt, David L. Neumann
Journal
Clinical Psychologist
Year
2023
Study design
Survey study
Participants
165
Open access
Yes
Original abstract

Objective: The present study examined the relationship between attachment and premenstrual symptoms, and the mediating role of maladaptive emotion regulation.Method: Attachment orientation, maladaptive emotion regulation, and premenstrual symptom severity were measured using a cross-sectional design among female university students who were naturally cycling (n = 165) or currently using hormonal contraception (HC) (n = 124).Results: Partial correlations, controlling for age, cycle regularity, and general symptoms of psychopathology (depression, anxiety, and stress), revealed positive associations between maladaptive emotion regulation and premenstrual symptoms, and between anxious attachment and maladaptive emotion regulation for both groups of women.Moreover, among women who were naturally cycling, maladaptive emotion regulation positively mediated the relationship between anxious (but not avoidant) attachment and premenstrual symptom severity; anxious attachment was associated with more severe premenstrual symptoms via increased maladaptive emotion regulation.This same mediation pathway was not observed for participants currently using HC.Conclusions: The findings highlight that a negative model of the self, which is characteristic of an anxious attachment style, may be a useful psychotherapeutic target for naturally cycling women who experience premenstrual symptoms.Further research and replication are required to confirm the potential moderating effect of HC and hormonal changes on these relationships. KEY POINTS What is already known about this topic:(1) Premenstrual symptoms affect approximately 70-90% of reproductive-age women.(2) Elevated premenstrual symptoms are associated with adverse psychological outcomes including lower health-related quality of life and increased risk of suicide.(3) Maladaptive emotion regulation has been implicated in heightened premenstrual symptom severity; however, the role of attachment style has been underexplored.What this topic adds:(1) Anxious attachment was associated with elevated premenstrual symptoms via maladaptive emotion regulation among women who were naturally cycling.(2) A negative model of the self may be the theoretical mechanism underlying the link between anxious attachment and premenstrual symptoms.(3) Psychotherapies that address underlying attachment insecurity may improve emotion regulation and, thus, reduce premenstrual symptom severity.

Reproduced under CC-BY.

Topics