Skip to content

Cohort study, 2023

What problems do Japanese doctors see in how PMS and PMDD are diagnosed and treated?

Most Japanese doctors diagnose PMS and PMDD without using the recommended symptom diary. Only 8.4% keep a diary and 84.4% use only informal interviews. Treatment relies mainly on birth control pills (98.1%) and herbal medicine (73.6%), with antidepressants used in just 2.6% of cases.

Early or limited evidence 1312 Japanese obstetricians and gynecologists

What they did

Cross-sectional survey of 1312 Japanese obstetricians and gynecologists (7.8% response rate) in 2021 about their current diagnosis and treatment practices for PMS and PMDD.

What they found

91.4% prefer to diagnose and treat PMS themselves rather than refer to psychiatrists. 96.6% treat PMS or PMDD routinely. For diagnosis: 84.4% use only informal interviews, 8.4% keep a symptom diary, 10.3% use a screening questionnaire. For treatment: 98.1% prescribe birth control pills, 73.6% prescribe Kampo (traditional Japanese herbal medicine), and 2.6% prescribe SSRIs (antidepressants). Among birth control types, 65.1% use drospirenone-ethinylestradriol.

What it means for you

Most Japanese doctors don't follow guidelines that recommend prospective symptom diaries for diagnosis. This describes practices in Japan only; we don't know if other countries differ.

1312

doctors surveyed

98.1%

prescribed birth control pills

2.6%

prescribed antidepressants

About the study

Original title
Current status and problems in the diagnosis and treatment of premenstrual syndrome and premenstrual dysphoric disorder from the perspective of obstetricians and gynecologists in Japan
Authors
Yoshimi K, Inoue F, Odai T et al.
Journal
The journal of obstetrics and gynaecology research
Year
2023
Study design
Cohort study
Participants
1,312
What was tested
None
Open access
Yes
Original abstract

Aim: To investigate the current status and problems in the diagnosis and treatment of premenstrual syndrome (PMS) and premenstrual dysphoric disorder (PMDD) from the perspective of obstetricians and gynecologists (OB/GYNs) in Japan, the Japanese Society of Obstetrics and Gynecology (JSOG) conducted a national-wide survey. Methods: An email survey was sent to all JSOG members (16 732) and a web-based survey was conducted using a Google form between September and November 2021. The current status and problems in PMS/PMDD diagnosis and treatment were surveyed in this cross-sectional study. Results: In total, 1312 respondents (7.8% of all JSOG members) completed the questionnaire. In terms of diagnoses and treatment, OB/GYN was preferred over psychiatrist for PMS (91.4% vs. 45%); however, no differences were noted for PMDD (76.1% vs. 73.7%). A total of 1267 (96.6%) respondents engaged in routine PMS/PMDD treatment. Regarding the general diagnosis procedure, 84.4% respondents answered "only a vague medical interview," 8.4% kept a two-cycle symptom diary, and 10.3% used a screening questionnaire. The most commonly used medication was oral contraceptive pills (OCPs) (98.1%), followed by the Kampo, traditional Japanese herbal medicines, Kamishoyosan (73.6%). Concerning first-line drugs for treatment, OCPs were the most common (76.8%), followed by Kampo medicine (19.5%); selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) were less frequently used (2.6%). Regarding first-line drugs among OCPs, 65.1% respondents reported drospirenone-ethinylestradriol use. Conclusions: This study indicates that only a few OB/GYNs practicing PMS/PMDD in Japan use a prospective diary, which is an essential diagnostic criterion for PMS/PMDD. Regarding treatment, SSRIs were used less frequently.

Reproduced under CC-BY.

Topics