Skip to content

Case-control study, 1992

Do women with PMS report more stress arousal than women without PMS during their cycle?

Yes. Women who self-diagnosed with PMS reported significantly greater increases in arousal during the premenstrual phase compared to women without PMS, though there were no differences in actual task performance.

Moderate study design Women with self-diagnosed PMS and women without PMS, including oral contraceptive users and naturally cycling women.

What they did

Researchers compared women who self-diagnosed with PMS to women without PMS, including some using oral contraceptives. They measured reported stress and arousal, performance on a word-matching task, and personality traits at premenstrual and other cycle phases.

What they found

All women reported increased arousal during the premenstrual phase, but PMS women reported significantly greater increases. There were no differences between groups in actual task performance. All women improved their word-matching performance during the premenstrual phase. Women with PMS scored higher on neuroticism and were more Type A personality.

What it means for you

PMS may relate more to how women perceive and react to stress than to actual changes in ability. Personality traits like neuroticism and Type A behavior appear connected to PMS. Stress management combined with attention to personality may help. Limitation: women self-diagnosed PMS without formal diagnosis, and results are from a case-control study.

About the study

Original title
Interactions between stress and performance during the menstrual cycle in relation to the premenstrual syndrome
Authors
Jane Maria Ussher, John M. Wilding
Journal
Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology
Year
1992
Study design
Case-control study

Topics