Skip to content

Survey study, 2024

Is mental health different in premenstrual exacerbation versus core premenstrual disorder?

Women with premenstrual exacerbation, where an existing mental health condition worsens before menstruation, had higher anxiety and depression and lower quality of life than women with core premenstrual disorder. This was a very small study.

Early or limited evidence 32 women in Japan seeking treatment for premenstrual symptoms (22 core PMD, 10 premenstrual exacerbation)

What they did

Cross-sectional study of 32 women seeking treatment for premenstrual symptoms at a hospital in Japan. Women were diagnosed using patient diaries as having either core premenstrual disorder or premenstrual exacerbation. They completed questionnaires about anxiety, depression, and quality of life.

What they found

Of 32 women diagnosed with premenstrual disorders, 22 had core premenstrual disorder and 10 had premenstrual exacerbation. All women with premenstrual exacerbation had an underlying psychiatric disorder. The premenstrual exacerbation group had higher levels of anxiety and depression. The premenstrual exacerbation group also had lower quality of life scores in most domains except physical and social functioning.

What it means for you

Women whose existing mental health conditions worsen before their period may experience more severe emotional symptoms and reduced quality of life than women whose symptoms appear only before menstruation. These women may need different or more intensive treatment. This is a very small study from a single hospital in Japan.

32

Total study participants

22

With core premenstrual disorder

10

With premenstrual exacerbation

About the study

Original title
Mental health and quality of life in patients with premenstrual exacerbation: a cross-sectional study in Japan
Authors
Ogawa M, Iioka Y, Takamatsu K
Journal
Journal of obstetrics and gynaecology : the journal of the Institute of Obstetrics and Gynaecology
Year
2024
Study design
Survey study
Participants
32
What was tested
Observational study comparing mental health and quality of life between women with different types of premenstrual disorders
Open access
Yes
Original abstract

Background: In the classification of premenstrual disorders (PMDs), premenstrual exacerbation (PME) is listed as one of the variants of PMDs, along with core PMD. However, the incidence of PME and its impact on mental health and quality of life have not been investigated. Therefore, we investigated the proportion of PME among women seeking treatment for premenstrual symptoms in Japan and compared the levels of anxiety, depression and quality of life between women with PME and those with core PMD. Methods: Women who presented to the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology of a single institute for treatment of premenstrual symptoms and were diagnosed with PMDs using patient diaries were included in the study. Based on the diagnosis, patients were divided into two groups (core PMD and PME) and their responses to a questionnaire on mental health and quality of life at the first visit were analysed. Results: A total of 32 women were diagnosed with PMDs (22 with core PMD and 10 with PME). All underlying medical conditions in women with PME were psychiatric disorders. There were no significant differences in various factors between the two groups. In terms of mental health, the PME group had higher levels of anxiety and depression than the core PMD group. Regarding quality of life, the PME group had lower scores than the core PMD group in all domains except physical and social functioning. Conclusions: Patients seeking treatment for premenstrual symptoms included many PME. Women with PME were more anxious and depressed than those with core PMD, and their quality of life was low in both physical and psychological domains. Patients with PME should be diagnosed and treated more appropriately.

Reproduced under CC-BY.

Topics