Skip to content

Non-randomised trial, 2022

Does eating red spinach pudding reduce PMS and painful period symptoms in teenage girls?

In this small Indonesian study, girls who ate red spinach pudding had a bigger drop in PMS symptom scores than girls who did not, and the difference was statistically significant, but the study was small and not randomized.

Early or limited evidence 60 adolescent girls in Indonesia with PMS and dysmenorrhea

What they did

60 adolescent girls were split into two groups in a quasi-experimental pretest-posttest study. One group ate red spinach pudding; the other did not. Researchers measured PMS scores before and after, and adjusted the results for BMI and hemoglobin levels.

What they found

The average PMS score dropped by 2.44 points in the pudding group versus 0.54 points in the control group, a mean difference of 2.98 (p = 0.009), meaning this difference was unlikely to be due to chance.

What it means for you

This hints that red spinach pudding could help ease PMS symptoms, possibly by supplying vitamins and minerals, but the study was small, not randomized, and done in one setting, so more research is needed before drawing firm conclusions.

2.44

PMS score drop, pudding group

0.54

PMS score drop, control group

0.009

p-value

About the study

Original title
Pengaruh Konsumsi Puding Bayam Merah terhadap Keluhan Dismenore dan Gejala Sindrom Premenstrual pada Remaja Putri
Authors
Ketut Resmaniasih
Journal
Jurnal Surya Medika
Year
2022
Study design
Non-randomised trial
Participants
60
What was tested
Consuming red spinach pudding, compared with a control group
Open access
Yes
Original abstract

Premenstrual syndrome (PMS) is a collection of symptoms caused by hormonal changes that last about two weeks before menstruation until the start. In addition to hormonal changes (an increased estrogen hormone), several other contributing factors include vitamin and mineral deficiencies such as vitamin B, calcium, magnesium, lack of physical activity, and stress. This study aimed to find out more clearly the effect of consuming red spinach pudding on complaints of dysmenorrhea and symptoms of premenstrual syndrome in adolescent girls. This study used a Quasy Experiment with a two-group pretest-posttest design with a total sample of 60 people. Based on the linear regression analysis results after controlling for the confounding variables BMI and HB levels, the mean reduction in PMS scores in the intervention group was 2.44 and in the control group was 0.54. The mean difference between groups was 2.98, with a p-value = 0.009. The results showed a decrease in the mean premenstrual syndrome score in the group of young women who consumed red spinach pudding.

Reproduced under CC-BY-SA.

Topics