Skip to content

Survey study, 2017

Do teenage girls today experience PMS differently than their mothers did at the same age?

Yes. Today's students recognize PMS more, have more severe symptoms, and use more strategies to cope than their mothers did at the same age.

Moderate study design 272 nursing students in Japan and 272 of their mothers.

What they did

Researchers surveyed 272 nursing students and 272 of their mothers between July and November 2016. They asked whether they recognized PMS, what physical and emotional symptoms they experienced, and what strategies they used to manage symptoms.

What they found

98% of students recognized PMS compared to 76% of mothers when they were the students' age. Students experienced more moderate to severe physical and emotional symptoms. Desire for sweets was the most common physical symptom and irritability was the most common emotional symptom. Students used more coping strategies than mothers had used. Physical symptoms in students showed a relationship with their mothers' symptoms.

What it means for you

Teenage girls today are more aware of PMS and experience symptoms more severely than their mothers did at the same age. This may reflect more available information and lifestyle changes. The connection between mothers' and daughters' symptoms suggests both genes and shared family factors matter.

272

Student-mother pairs studied

98%

Students who recognized PMS

76%

Mothers who recognized PMS at students' age

About the study

Original title
Premenstrual symptoms in young students and in their mothers at their ages
Authors
Fukuoka Miwa, Hamada Yuna, Fujikawa Mari et al.
Journal
International Journal of Nursing and Midwifery
Year
2017
Study design
Survey study
Participants
272
What was tested
No intervention. Survey comparing two generations.
Open access
Yes
Original abstract

Premenstrual symptoms are gradually becoming recognized socially and measures taken to cope with premenstrual symptoms are changing. The purpose of this study was to determine the differences in degree of recognition, in physical and emotional symptoms and in means for coping with premenstrual symptoms between nursing students and their mothers at the ages of the nursing students. This study was conducted between July and November, 2016. 272 nursing students and 272 mothers of the students were recruited. This study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Tokushima University Hospital. A self-administered questionnaire that took about 15 min to complete was designed. The proportion of students who recognized premenstrual symptoms was 98% and the proportion of mothers who recognized premenstrual symptoms at the same age as the students was 76%. The proportions of students who had moderate to severe physical and emotional symptoms were higher than those of the mothers. The items with the highest percentages of students and mothers who answered moderate to severe physical and emotional symptoms were desire for sweets and irritability, respectively. The proportion of students who took measures to cope with premenstrual symptoms was higher than that of the mothers. Physical symptoms in the students were significantly correlated with those in their mothers. The degrees of physical and emotional symptoms in the students were greater than those in the mothers at the same age as the students and measures taken for coping with these symptoms were diversified. The increasing availability of information on premenstrual symptoms and changes in lifestyle may contribute to the increase in prevalence of premenstrual symptoms. Key words: Premenstrual symptoms, coping, nursing students, mothers.

Reproduced under CC-BY.

Topics