Skip to content

Case-control study, 2013

How does the menstrual cycle affect processing emotions and thinking in women with and without PMS?

All women took longer to resolve conflicts between emotions and thinking during the luteal phase. Only women with PMS showed increased stress levels during the luteal phase, suggesting an additional stress response.

Early or limited evidence 15 women with PMS and 15 women without PMS

What they did

Researchers measured performance on an emotional conflict task and stress levels in 15 women with PMS and 15 women without PMS throughout their menstrual cycle. The emotional conflict task measured how quickly women could resolve situations where emotions and logical thinking conflicted.

What they found

All women showed a significant increase in reaction time for resolving emotional conflict from the follicular to the luteal phase (p=0.001). Only women with PMS showed an increase in physiological and subjective stress measures during the luteal phase.

What it means for you

The menstrual cycle affects how all women process emotions and thinking together, but women with PMS experience additional stress during the premenstrual period. This extra stress may explain why women with PMS struggle more. The study was small and described as a pilot study.

15

women with PMS

15

women without PMS

p=0.001

significance for increased reaction time in luteal phase

About the study

Original title
Menstrual cycle phase modulates emotional conflict processing in women with and without premenstrual syndrome (PMS)--a pilot study
Authors
Hoyer J, Burmann I, Kieseler ML et al.
Journal
PloS one
Year
2013
Study design
Case-control study
Participants
15
What was tested
Menstrual cycle phase
Open access
Yes
Original abstract

Background: Premenstrual syndrome (PMS) is characterized by a cluster of psychological and somatic symptoms during the late luteal phase of the menstrual cycle that disappear after the onset of menses. Behavioral differences in emotional and cognitive processing have been reported in women with PMS, and it is of particular interest whether PMS affects the parallel execution of emotional and cognitive processing. Related to this is the question of how the performance of women with PMS relates to stress levels compared to women without PMS. Cortisol has been shown to affect emotional processing in general and it has also been shown that women with severe PMS have a particular cortisol profile. Methods: We measured performance in an emotional conflict task and stress levels in women with PMS (n = 15) and women without PMS (n = 15) throughout their menstrual cycle. Results: We found a significant increase (p = 0.001) in the mean reaction time for resolving emotional conflict from the follicular to the luteal cycle phase in all subjects. Only women with PMS demonstrated an increase in physiological and subjective stress measures during the luteal menstrual cycle phase. Conclusions: Our findings suggest that the menstrual cycle modulates the integration of emotional and cognitive processing in all women. Preliminary data are supportive of the secondary hypothesis that stress levels are mediated by the menstrual cycle phase only in women with PMS. The presented evidence for menstrual cycle-specific differences in integrating emotional and cognitive information highlights the importance of controlling for menstrual cycle phase in studies that aim to elucidate the interplay of emotion and cognition.

Reproduced under CC-BY.

Topics