Skip to content

Survey study, 2017

Do girls with clinically significant PMS have worse quality of life than those without it?

Yes. Girls with clinically significant PMS reported much worse overall quality of life. While 12% had poor quality of life in the PMS group, none did in the group without PMS.

Moderate study design 600 female students in Egypt (300 with clinically significant PMS, 300 without)

What they did

A comparative cross-sectional study of 600 female students in Egypt. 300 had clinically significant PMS and 300 did not. PMS severity was assessed with the Premenstrual Symptoms Screening Tool and quality of life was measured with the RAND 36-item Health Survey Questionnaire.

What they found

Girls with clinically significant PMS had significantly lower overall quality of life. In the CSPMS group, 12% had poor quality of life and 86% had fair quality of life. In the group without CSPMS, none had poor quality of life. The most negatively affected areas were social functioning, role limitations due to physical health, role limitations due to emotional problems, energy and fatigue, and emotional well-being. Physical functioning and general health perception were least affected. Bodily pain was not affected at all.

What it means for you

Severe PMS substantially impacts girls' daily activities, emotions, and social life. This was one university in Egypt, so results may differ in other countries. The study shows that treating severe PMS matters for overall wellbeing during the teenage years.

600

Total female students

12%

With poor quality of life in PMS group (versus 0% in non-PMS group)

86%

With fair quality of life in PMS group

About the study

Original title
Quality of Life Among Girls with or Without Clinically Significant Premenstrual Syndrome
Authors
Wafaa T Elgzar
Journal
American Journal of Nursing Science
Year
2017
Study design
Survey study
Participants
600
What was tested
None
Open access
Yes
Original abstract

Premenstrual syndrome (PMS) is one of the most vague and ill-defined phenomena in the field of woman health. Almost all its definitions concluded that it is a cyclic recurrence of distressing physical, psychological and behavioral symptoms, that occur during the luteal phase of menstrual cycle and evaporates within two days of the onset of menses. PMS may range in its severity from mild (90% of females) to moderate or severe (12.6-31% of females). The last type is called Clinically Significant Premenstrual Syndrome (CSPMS). The emergence of CSPMS during the teen years complicates the process of puberty and assumed to have negative impact on the girl's Health Related Quality of Life (HRQOL). This study aimed to compare HRQOL in the girls with and without CSPMS. This was a comparative study which was carried out on 600 female students (300 free from CSPMS and 300 suffer from CSPMS) at Damanhur University, Elbehira governorate, Egypt. A modified version of Premenstrual Symptoms Screening Tool (PMSST) for clinicians was used to assess the severity of subject's PMS. Each subject was assigned to either CSPMS free group or CSPMS group based on the severity of their PMS symptoms. Then the HRQOL was assessed in the two groups, using a translated version of RAND36- item Health Survey Questionnaire. The study results indicated a statistically significant difference between the two groups in their total quality of life score. The quality of life among the free group was almost equally good or fair while poor quality of life was found among around one tenth (12%) of CSPMS group compared to none among the free group. The largest proportion (86%) among CSPMS group had fair quality of life. The most negatively affected domains were social functioning, role limitations due to physical health, role limitations due to emotional problems, energy/fatigue and emotional well-being respectively. The least affected domains were physical functioning and general health perception. On the other hand, bodily pain wasn't affected at all. The study findings revealed that girls with CSPMS suffer from poorer health-related quality of life than those without CSMPS. Appropriate PMS management strategies should be initiated in order to improve the health related quality of life among girls with CSPMS. The culture of silence surrounding PMS should be broken by focusing on researches that highlight its importance and negative impact on quality of life.

Reproduced under CC-BY.

Topics