Non-randomised trial, 2011
Do contraceptive patches work better than contraceptive pills for adolescents?
Patch and pills had similar effects on mood, periods, and side effects over 9 cycles. Fewer people continued using the patch long-term, with 38% of patch users versus 60% of pill users still using their method after 9 cycles.
What they did
Followed 80 adolescents aged 13-22 (40 using contraceptive patch, 40 using pills) for up to 9 cycles, tracking whether they continued using the method, how consistently they used it, and their reported mood changes and side effects.
What they found
After 9 cycles, 38% of patch users and 60% of pill users were still using their chosen method. There were no differences between the groups in consistent use, quality of life, or side effects. Both groups reported lighter and more predictable periods and less depression before their period. Only pill users reported improvement in premenstrual anger. Patch users were slightly more likely to report that their method improved daily activities.
What it means for you
Contraceptive patch and pills have similar effects on mood and periods in adolescents. However, adolescents are more likely to stick with pills long-term, so despite the convenience of weekly dosing, the patch may not be the better choice for sustained use in this age group.
38%
Patch users continuing after 9 cycles
60%
Pill users continuing after 9 cycles
40
Number of adolescents per group
About the study
- Original title
- Adolescents' experiences using the contraceptive patch versus pills
- Authors
- Sucato GS, Land SR, Murray PJ et al.
- Journal
- Journal of pediatric and adolescent gynecology
- Year
- 2011
- Study design
- Non-randomised trial
- What was tested
- Contraceptive patch versus daily contraceptive pills
- Read the paper
- doi.org/10.1016/j.jpag.2011.02.001
Topics
Related studies
Randomised trial, 2025
Does mood, well-being, and sexual function change across the menstrual cycle?
Survey study, 2025
What are menstrual cycle patterns in elite female basketball players?
Study, 2022
What are the symptoms, causes, and treatments of PMS and PMDD?
Study, 2010
What gynecologic problems do girls with Down syndrome, autism, and cerebral palsy experience?
Systematic review, 2020
How common is PMS among women of reproductive age in Ethiopia?
Review, 2009
What causes PMDD and what are the treatment options?