Skip to content

Survey study, 2018

Do Asian and Caucasian women experience different PMS symptoms?

Yes. Asian women reported significantly higher rates of mood swings, depression, food cravings, digestive problems, and menstrual cramps, and had shorter menstrual periods.

Early or limited evidence 47 Asian and 47 Caucasian women aged 18-55 with PMS living in Denmark

What they did

Online survey of women with PMS living in Denmark. 47 were Asian and 47 were Caucasian, aged 18-55. Participants completed a 36-question questionnaire about their PMS symptoms.

What they found

Asian women had higher ratings of mood swings, depression and food cravings (p < 0.05) compared to Caucasian women. Asian women also had higher rates of digestion problems (p < 0.05), higher rates of cramps and nausea during menstruation, and shorter menstruation periods (p < 0.05).

What it means for you

There may be ethnic differences in how women experience PMS, but the reasons are unclear and could involve genetics, environment, or other factors. The sample was small and only in Denmark, so findings may not apply to other populations.

47

Asian women

47

Caucasian women

18-55

age range in years

About the study

Original title
Premenstrual Syndrome Characteristics in Caucasian and Asian Women: A Survey - Based Study in Denmark
Authors
Anahita Nikbakht, Parisa Gazerani
Journal
Current Opinion in Gynecology and Obstetrics
Year
2018
Study design
Survey study
What was tested
None - observational survey
Open access
Yes
Original abstract

Women of reproductive age present one or more emotional or physical symptoms in premenstrual phase of their menstrual cycle, which is collectively called premenstrual syndrome (PMS). Estimates show that about 5 to 8% of women suffer from severe PMS. This form has been termed as premenstrual dysphoric disorder (PMDD). Diagnostic criteria have been proposed for PMDD. For the purpose of this research work, the term PMS was used to include variants of premenstrual syndrome in general. Common symptoms include but not limited to breast swelling, food cravings, bloating, mood swings and backache. The etiology of PMS remains unclear; but available evidence suggests that genetics and environmental factors may influence the PMS experience and its severity. The present study was designed to investigate PMS experience and characteristics in two ethnic groups of Caucasian and Asian women living in Denmark. An online survey-based methodology was applied to target Asians and Caucasians women (18-55 years) with PMS, living in different regions in Denmark. The questionnaire consisted of 36 questions to cover the required information for the purpose of this study. Regression analysis was applied to find the association between PMSassociated factors and ethnicity. Asian (47) in comparison with Caucasian women (47) presented with higher ratings of several PMS symptoms such as mood swings, depression and food cravings (p < 0.05). Asian women were also found with higher rate in digestion problems (p < 0.05) and higher rate of cramps and nausea during menstruation and a shorter menstruation period compared with the Caucasians (p < 0.05). This study highlighted that Asian women had higher rates of both psychological and physiological factors in relation to PMS. Potential reasons for a difference between Asian and Caucasian women living in Demark is not clear, and need further investigation.

Reproduced under CC-BY.

Topics